One-Minute Summary: We, for one, are very glad October is over. See below for what we think has gone on. When all markets correct, we usually find it’s a good idea for the dust to settle and see what has fundamentally changed. As we’re fond of saying, prices change more than facts and the last few weeks have seen investors hitting the sell button and asking questions later.
The markets finished higher for the week but still had one of their worst months for some time. Earnings were phenomenal with the weighted average growth rate at 24%...that’s up from 19% a week ago but that's what happens when big index weightings like Google, Apple and Facebook turn in 30% to 40% growth rates. The market looks very oversold to us. Expect healthier markets once November elections are done.
1. Look back in anger: October was not kind to investors. The S&P 500 was down 7%, small caps down 11%, the Dow Transportation down 8%, the NASDAQ down 8% (and at one point down 12%), most Asian markets down 9% and most European markets down 8% to 9%. The best performing market was Switzerland, down 0.5% and the worst Korea, down 14%. The first is all about haven status and the second is a bellwether for global trade.
Was it better in bonds? Yes, but still negative. The U.S. broad bond market fell 0.9%. U.S. corporates and High Yield and international bonds were down nearly 2%. The best bond market was German Bunds where 10-Year yields fell from 0.5% to 0.3% but that was all a flight to quality as Italian spreads widened out.
Now what does it mean when all asset classes are hit?
A few misplaced remarks. In this case, renewal of the China tariffs and Powell’s hawkish talk on the natural interest rate.
A few missteps on the geo-political stage. In this case, the killing of Jamal Khashoggi, with all Saudi oil market at risk and the midterms, which are, you know, different.
A few highly leveraged trades. In this case, U.S. tech index, which had been a no-lose proposition all year.
A few missed earnings. We already mentioned companies like CAT and MMM which narrowly missed revenue or earnings, or cautioned on the 2019 outlook.
A few missed economic numbers. In this case, ISM manufacturing, trade, capital goods.
No “Fear” trades. In this case, markets did not head to the classic safety trades of gold, yen, Bunds and T-Bills. So, it wasn't a move from “risk to safety” but a general rout.
It's Pelion on Ossa and the best thing to do is step out of the way. Not every market twist requires action and decisions made at heated times rarely turn out well (see #17 here). Here’s what we know:
Company earnings: are strong. They're near the peak but that means they won't grow as much, not that they're about to swan dive. Corporate repurchases will start again soon.
Economy: also strong. Low unemployment and low inflation. But the twin deficits (trade and budget) are about to get worse. That’s a concern not a disaster.
Leverage: in some areas like leveraged loans and High Yield. But not really in banks, consumer (yes, we know the student debt story).
Corporate America: not happy with import prices and uncertainty (see some of the comments in the latest ISM report here). But also still moving ahead, not shedding labor (quite the opposite) or reducing capacity.
Slowing growth: the economy can not handle 4% growth and S&P 500 companies can not turn out 20% earnings growth year over year. That’s an adjustment not a hard recession. And it’s generally good for bonds.
Monetary policy works with a 12-24 month lag: the increase in rates in the last 12-months is now showing up as a slower economy. Slower, not stopped.
We put all those together and would expect more volatility…as we've said before, volatility was way too low in 2017 and most of 2018….what we have now is normal. The numbers will change very quickly. Two days ago, we had a YTD performance of the S&P 500 of 1.4%. Today it's 2.5%. Once we get through this month we fully expect quieter markets and Treasuries to steady.
We’re fans of history so we’ll use that as an excuse to pull out an important chart.
For the last five years, a 60/40 equity to bond portfolio returned 6.5% or 70% of the S&P 500 but with 40% less volatility. Longer numbers give an even better trade off.
Market volatility may produce opportunities for tactical traders but preservation of financial and mental capital is more important in our world (h/t Cameron Crise).
2. Jobs. The October jobs numbers were going to surprise because the last two months saw hurricanes that distorted the numbers. The way the BLS calculates the people in work is to ask, “were you paid anything last week?” If you weren’t, you're not counted as employed. This is fine if you're paid semi-monthly or monthly. There is no change to the numbers employed. But it's different if you're paid hourly. If you miss a few days because you’re trying to get out of the way of a storm, you fall off the payrolls. If you then come back to work the following week, it counts as a new job. It sounds confusing but what it means is that the new job numbers tend to score first, lower and then higher than trend in the months around hurricane disruptions.
And here it is:
We think the trend growth in employment is around 200,000 a month so at first this looks like a continuation of a trend rather than a break to new higher levels. Labor participation rose a little, but as we wrote last week, it’s not about to hit any new highs.
The one data point that caught the press’ attention was the white line, showing Average Hourly Earnings up 3.1% over the year…the fastest wage growth since 2009.
Yes, okay, but last October saw wages decline in nominal terms so the year-over-year comparison is highly distorted and we don't think for a second that wages are about to break out into some new sunny upland. Earlier in the week, we saw a much better indicator of wages and salaries and it looks like this:
That blue bar is the real increase in wages and benefits. Sometimes it goes up not because employees are paid more but because inflation dropped. As we mentioned before, there are lots of ways to get a pay increase but the only one we’re really interested in is if compensation grows significantly higher than inflation. It hasn’t.
Look, nothing here is going to change the Fed’s mind about December. Some even think the Fed may raise rates at their next meeting on November 7th. The tradition of only announcing rate increases when there’s a scheduled presser is new…we remember the days when the Fed opened its doors at 8:30, told you what the rate was and closed up. But, no, they’re not going to do anything on election day. We're all set for a December meeting.
What would change their mind? In order:
Economic growth stalling badly.
A big equity market correction…more than 20%.
Politics (the President rattles Mr. Powell).
A big international event, say, an Emerging Markets melt down.
Commodity prices fall.
Which is another way of saying, it ain’t gonna happen.
3. Peak Apple: No, probably not. Yes, it lost its $1tr market cap (so did Amazon but by a much bigger miss) but it's still up 22% this year, earns a 40% return on equity, and will spend around $100bn in share buybacks, which is enough to buy any of 450 companies in the S&P 500. Those of you so inclined will note that it has been a great timing investment when it falls to 12 times earnings (shaded area) but it's not there yet.
Bottom Line: As last week, we would still look at protecting the portfolio where we can and invested in Treasury FRNs. We think there will be some restoration of confidence in coming weeks and would expect the bond market to stabilize and recover first.
Please check out our 119 Years of the Dow chart
Subscribe here for our investment updates
--Christian Thwaites, Brouwer & Janachowski, LLC
Please note that this discussion of our investments and investment strategy (including our research and investment process) represents our investments and investment strategy at the date of this commentary, and is subject to change without notice. We cannot assure that the type of investments discussed in this commentary will outperform any other investment strategy in the future, nor can we guarantee that such investments will present the best or an attractive risk-adjusted investment in the future. This is for general informational purposes only; references to an individual security should not be construed as a recommendation to buy or sell that security. The securities mentioned in this commentary are only several of the successful as well as unsuccessful investments by us, and do not represent all of the securities we have purchased, sold or recommended. Although we deem reliable the sources of the statistical and other information referred to in this commentary, we cannot guarantee the accuracy or completeness of any statements or numerical data. Past performance is no indication of future results.
All charts from Factset unless otherwise noted.